So, as you may or may not know, I am a YouTube "Bedroom Guitarist". You know the ones I'm talking about, you do a search for a music video on YouTube and instead of what you are after you are inundated with an array of headless guitarists sat in their bedrooms or living rooms playing along to the song you were looking for. There are thousands of us out there. Many from the Far East, (Japan and Korea mostly), countless hoards from the US, and probably just as many from all across Europe. All united by our love of guitar driven music and the need every guitar player has to learn their favourite songs! Thanks to the power and simplicity of YouTube it is now possible for us to share our passion with the whole world. Although, admittedly, it's usually only other guitarists who watch our videos, that's ok because that's exactly the audience we are playing for. It's a great way to challenge, impress and, above all, inspire each other into furthering our knowledge and ability. It's our way of paying tribute to our favourite bands and songs. Just good clean fun!
But in recent months something has happened that threatens the future of our little community. YouTube owners Google have quietly gotten into bed with some big record companies. It seems that when a mega-corporation like Universal or Warner take YouTube to task over copyright violations, they threaten court action, but often settle for becoming partners in the company. In a business sense of the word, obviously. As partners, they are entitled to scan every single video hosted on YouTube, (using a piece of software that does it automatically mind you, there is no human input into this, so there is no differentiation between somebody posting the original song over a picture and a cover video). Now they are flagging our cover versions as Copyright infringement and are removing them from the site, sometimes without notice. Usually you are notified of the removal and allowed to lodge an appeal which can buy a few weeks grace, but at the end of the day the record company that made the initial complaint has the final say, and as such all appeals that I know of have been rejected and the song has been removed.
Yesterday the appeal I had lodged against Warner Music Group against the removal of my cover of Black Sabbath's "War Pigs" was rejected and the video was removed from YouTube. I had appealed on the grounds of "Fair Use". My covers aren't for profit, obviously no-one's going to PAY me to do this stuff! One of the other criteria for fair use is the amount of original material used. In my case the whole song was used as a backing track, but with my guitar screeching all over the top of it, and the fact it's recorded through the built in mic on a digital camera, means that the quality of the original track is diminished so substantially as to be of no use to anyone. Face it, if the only choices you had to listen to War Pigs was to go out and buy a legitimate copy or to listen to my cover version for free, you'd buy the fucking song!
There are also exemptions for educational or parody purposes, both of which could loosely apply to my vids, eg, how NOT to do it, and I'm so bad it could be classed as a parody of the original, in the style of Les Dawson's piano playing :)
The final criteria for a "fair use" exemption is how adversely the usage of the original material will affect it's monetary worth. Speaking more broadly now about the whole cover versions scene, I'd have to say that these videos actually promote the bands in question. It's not as if we are posting full quality soundtracks that people can listen to instead of spending money, so there's no negative effect there. I follow a few of these guys, one of whom is a drummer who plays Strapping Young Lad songs, now, he also covers Gojira songs, a band I had never even heard of before seeing one of this guys cover videos. I now own the two most recent Gojira albums, money in the bank for their record company entirely off the back of a YouTube cover video. These idiots who are ploughing in so heavy handedly are actually going to end up costing themselves money! Jerks.
Here's a video by bass monster ZodiakIronFist who explains it all way better than me!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fUKPg4doUsIf you happen to see this and agree with our point of view, please comment on the video page, or in my comments section, and pass the link on to all your friends! We need all the support we can get if we are going to get these fuckers to see sense.
Anyway, that's it. War Pigs denied. Fuck all I can do about it. Just waiting now for my other videos to start getting pulled.
Tribute is NOT theft. Rock on dudes \m/